Hone logo
Hone
Problems

Implementing Compare-and-Swap (CAS) Operations in Python

This challenge focuses on implementing the fundamental Compare-and-Swap (CAS) atomic operation in Python. CAS is a crucial building block for concurrent programming, enabling safe updates to shared data without explicit locks. Mastering CAS is essential for understanding and building robust multi-threaded applications.

Problem Description

Your task is to implement a CASLock class that mimics the behavior of a Compare-and-Swap operation on a shared integer value. The CASLock class should provide two primary methods:

  1. compare_and_swap(self, old_value, new_value): This method attempts to atomically update the internal value. It takes an old_value and a new_value.

    • If the current internal value matches old_value, the internal value is updated to new_value, and the method returns True.
    • If the current internal value does not match old_value, the internal value remains unchanged, and the method returns False.

  2. get_value(self): This method returns the current internal value.

Key Requirements:

  • The compare_and_swap operation must be atomic. This means that even in a multi-threaded environment, no two threads should be able to interfere with the check-and-update sequence. If thread A checks the value, sees X, and thread B concurrently changes it to Y before thread A can update it to Z, thread A's update should fail.
  • The internal value is an integer.
  • The CASLock class should be initialized with an initial integer value.

Expected Behavior:

When compare_and_swap is called, it should either successfully update the value and return True, or fail to update and return False. get_value should always return the current, most recently set value.

Edge Cases:

  • Multiple threads attempting to perform compare_and_swap concurrently on the same CASLock instance.
  • Calling compare_and_swap with the same old_value multiple times.
  • Calling compare_and_swap with old_value that does not match the current value.

Examples

Example 1:

# Assume a single-threaded execution for simplicity in this example
cas_lock = CASLock(10)
print(cas_lock.get_value())  # Output: 10

# Successful CAS
success1 = cas_lock.compare_and_swap(10, 20)
print(success1)             # Output: True
print(cas_lock.get_value())  # Output: 20

# Failed CAS
success2 = cas_lock.compare_and_swap(10, 30)
print(success2)             # Output: False
print(cas_lock.get_value())  # Output: 20

Explanation: Initially, the value is 10. The first compare_and_swap successfully changes it to 20 because the old_value (10) matched. The second compare_and_swap fails because the old_value (10) no longer matches the current value (20).

Example 2:

import threading

class CASLock:
    def __init__(self, initial_value):
        self._value = initial_value
        self._lock = threading.Lock() # We'll use this for atomicity in Python

    def compare_and_swap(self, old_value, new_value):
        with self._lock: # Acquire lock to ensure atomicity
            if self._value == old_value:
                self._value = new_value
                return True
            return False

    def get_value(self):
        with self._lock: # Lock for consistent reads
            return self._value

# Scenario with multiple threads
cas_lock = CASLock(0)
num_threads = 5
increments_per_thread = 1000

def worker(lock, count):
    for _ in range(count):
        # Spin until CAS is successful
        while True:
            current_val = lock.get_value()
            if lock.compare_and_swap(current_val, current_val + 1):
                break

threads = []
for _ in range(num_threads):
    t = threading.Thread(target=worker, args=(cas_lock, increments_per_thread))
    threads.append(t)
    t.start()

for t in threads:
    t.join()

print(f"Final value: {cas_lock.get_value()}")
# Expected Output: Final value: 5000 (5 threads * 1000 increments)

Explanation: In this multi-threaded example, each worker thread tries to increment the shared cas_lock value by 1, 1000 times. The while True loop with compare_and_swap ensures that the increment operation is performed atomically. If the compare_and_swap fails (meaning another thread modified the value between reading and attempting to swap), the loop retries with the updated value. The final value should be the sum of all increments across all threads.

Constraints

  • The internal value will always be an integer.
  • The maximum initial value and subsequent values will not exceed 2^31 - 1.
  • The number of threads attempting concurrent CAS operations can be significant (e.g., up to 100).
  • Your implementation should be able to handle these concurrent operations efficiently without deadlocks.

Notes

  • In Python, direct low-level atomic operations similar to C++ or Java's hardware-level CAS are not readily available for arbitrary Python objects or simple integers in the same way. To simulate atomicity for this challenge, you will likely need to use Python's threading synchronization primitives, such as threading.Lock, to protect the critical section where the value is read and potentially updated. This simulates the atomic behavior of CAS.
  • Consider how to design your compare_and_swap method to ensure that the read of the current value and the write of the new value happen as an indivisible operation from the perspective of other threads.
  • The core idea of CAS is to avoid blocking threads by retrying the operation if it fails due to a concurrent modification. Your multi-threaded example should demonstrate this retry mechanism.
Loading editor...
python